Physlib

PhyslibAlpha.QuantumMechanics.OperatorAlgebra.States.Uncertainty

Uncertainty relations

Positivity of a state gives a Cauchy--Schwarz inequality for expectation values. Applied to centered observables, this yields the Robertson--Schrödinger and Robertson uncertainty relations.

Cauchy--Schwarz

Uncertainty relations

9 declarations

theorem

$\unicode{x2045} a - \omega(a)\mathbb{1}, b - \omega(b)\mathbb{1} \unicode{x2045} = \unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2045}$

Let AA be a unital complex C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A, let δa=a−ω(a)1\delta a = a - \omega(a)\mathbb{1} and δb=b−ω(b)1\delta b = b - \omega(b)\mathbb{1} be the centered observables representing the fluctuations of aa and bb around their mean values. Then the Lie bracket of the centered observables is equal to the Lie bracket of the original observables: \[ \unicode{x2045} \delta a, \delta b \unicode{x2046} = \unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2046} \] where the bracket $\unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2046}$ is defined as the imaginary part of the product abab, which is proportional to the commutator [a,b][a, b]. This identity reflects that the commutator only depends on the fluctuations of the operators and is invariant under a shift by their expectation values.

theorem

$\omega(\delta a \delta b) = \text{cov}_\omega(a, b) + i \omega\langle \unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2046} \rangle$

Let AA be a complex unital C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (self-adjoint elements), let δa=a−ω⟨a⟩1\delta a = a - \omega\langle a \rangle \mathbb{1} and δb=b−ω⟨b⟩1\delta b = b - \omega\langle b \rangle \mathbb{1} be the centered observables representing the fluctuations of aa and bb around their mean values. The expectation value of the product of these fluctuations decomposes into a real symmetric part (the covariance) and an imaginary antisymmetric part (the expectation of the bracket) as follows: \[ \omega(\delta a \delta b) = \text{cov}_\omega(a, b) + i \omega\langle \unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2046} \rangle \] where covω(a,b)\text{cov}_\omega(a, b) is the covariance of aa and bb in state ω\omega, ii is the imaginary unit, and $\unicode{x2045} a, b \unicode{x2046}$ is the Lie bracket of the observables, defined as the imaginary part of their product 12i(ab−ba)\frac{1}{2i}(ab - ba).

theorem

Cauchy–Schwarz inequality for the GNS sesquilinear form of a state

Let AA be an operator algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any elements x,y∈Ax, y \in A, the following inequality holds: ∥ω(x∗y)∥⋅∥ω(y∗x)∥≤Re⁡(ω(x∗x))⋅Re⁡(ω(y∗y)) \|\omega(x^* y)\| \cdot \|\omega(y^* x)\| \le \operatorname{Re}(\omega(x^* x)) \cdot \operatorname{Re}(\omega(y^* y)) where x∗x^* denotes the adjoint (or star) of xx, ω(a)\omega(a) is the expectation value of an element aa under the state ω\omega, and ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| denotes the complex modulus. This is the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality for the positive sesquilinear form (often associated with the GNS construction) induced by the state ω\omega.

theorem

ω(ba)=ω(ab)‾\omega(ba) = \overline{\omega(ab)} for observables a,ba, b

Let AA be a C∗C^*-algebra. For any state ω\omega on AA and any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (self-adjoint elements such that a=a∗a = a^* and b=b∗b = b^*), the value of the state on the product baba is the complex conjugate of the value of the state on the product abab. That is, ω(ba)=ω(ab)‾.\omega(ba) = \overline{\omega(ab)}. This identity allows for the reversal of the order of two observables within a state by applying complex conjugation.

theorem

∥ω(aˉbˉ)∥⋅∥ω(bˉaˉ)∥≤varω(a)⋅varω(b)\|\omega(\bar{a}\bar{b})\| \cdot \|\omega(\bar{b}\bar{a})\| \le \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) for observables a,ba, b

Let AA be a C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (self-adjoint elements), let aˉ=a−ω(a)1\bar{a} = a - \omega(a)\mathbb{1} and bˉ=b−ω(b)1\bar{b} = b - \omega(b)\mathbb{1} denote the centered observables, representing the fluctuations of aa and bb around their expectation values. Then the product of the magnitudes of the correlation and its adjoint is bounded by the product of their variances: ∥ω(aˉbˉ)∥⋅∥ω(bˉaˉ)∥≤varω(a)⋅varω(b) \|\omega(\bar{a}\bar{b})\| \cdot \|\omega(\bar{b}\bar{a})\| \le \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) where ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| denotes the complex modulus and varω(x)=ω(xˉ2)\text{var}_\omega(x) = \omega(\bar{x}^2) is the variance of the observable xx in the state ω\omega. This inequality serves as the foundation for various uncertainty relations, asserting that the correlation between fluctuations cannot exceed the product of their spreads.

theorem

∣ω(ΔaΔb)∣2≤varω(a)⋅varω(b)|\omega(\Delta a \Delta b)|^2 \leq \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) for centered observables a,ba, b

Let AA be a unital complex C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (self-adjoint elements), let Δa=a−ω(a)1\Delta a = a - \omega(a)\mathbb{1} and Δb=b−ω(b)1\Delta b = b - \omega(b)\mathbb{1} denote the centered observables, where ω(a)\omega(a) is the expectation value. Then the following inequality holds: ∣ω(ΔaΔb)∣2≤varω(a)⋅varω(b) |\omega(\Delta a \Delta b)|^2 \leq \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) where varω(a)=ω((Δa)2)\text{var}_\omega(a) = \omega((\Delta a)^2) and varω(b)=ω((Δb)2)\text{var}_\omega(b) = \omega((\Delta b)^2) are the variances of the observables aa and bb in the state ω\omega.

theorem

Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty inequality: $\text{cov}_\omega(a, b)^2 + \omega\langle\unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046}\rangle^2 \le \text{var}_\omega(a) \text{var}_\omega(b)$

Let AA be a unital complex C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (self-adjoint elements), the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty inequality holds: \[ \text{cov}_\omega(a, b)^2 + \omega \langle \unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046} \rangle^2 \le \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) \] where covω(a,b)\text{cov}_\omega(a, b) is the covariance of the observables in state ω\omega, varω\text{var}_\omega is the variance, and $\unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046} = \text{Im}(ab) = \frac{1}{2i}(ab - ba)$ is the Lie bracket representing the imaginary part of their product. This inequality jointly bounds the covariance and the expectation of the commutator by the product of the individual variances.

theorem

Cauchy–Schwarz inequality for covariance: covω(a,b)2≤varω(a)⋅varω(b)\text{cov}_\omega(a, b)^2 \leq \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b)

Let AA be a unital complex C∗C^*-algebra and ω\omega be a state on AA. For any two observables a,b∈Aa, b \in A (represented as self-adjoint elements), the square of their covariance covω(a,b)\text{cov}_\omega(a, b) is bounded by the product of their respective variances varω(a)\text{var}_\omega(a) and varω(b)\text{var}_\omega(b): covω(a,b)2≤varω(a)⋅varω(b) \text{cov}_\omega(a, b)^2 \leq \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) This inequality implies that two observables cannot be more correlated than the product of their uncertainties (standard deviations) allows, which corresponds to the familiar relation ∣covω(a,b)∣≤σaσb|\text{cov}_\omega(a, b)| \leq \sigma_a \sigma_b obtained by omitting the commutator term in the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relation.

theorem

Robertson Uncertainty Relation: $\text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) \geq \omega\langle \unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046} \rangle^2$

Let AA be a C∗C^*-algebra, ω\omega be a state on AA, and a,b∈Aa, b \in A be observables (self-adjoint elements). Let $\unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046} = \text{Im}(ab) = \frac{1}{2i}(ab - ba)$ denote the Lie bracket of the observables. The Robertson uncertainty relation states that the product of the variances of aa and bb in the state ω\omega is bounded below by the square of the expectation value of their bracket: \[ \omega\langle \unicode{x2045}a, b\unicode{x2046} \rangle^2 \leq \text{var}_\omega(a) \cdot \text{var}_\omega(b) \] where ω⟨⋅⟩\omega\langle \cdot \rangle denotes the expectation value and varω(⋅)\text{var}_\omega(\cdot) denotes the variance.