PhyslibAlpha.ProbabilisticTheory.Classical.UniqueDecomposition
Uniqueness of pure decompositions
i. Overview
When ensembles refine, every state has at most one pure decomposition. This is the uniqueness half of the Choquet–Meyer theorem.
A measure on the pure states is fixed by the averages it gives to continuous functions. We test it on special functions: the largest of finitely many expectation values, `ω ↦ max (ω A₁) … (ω Aₙ)`. Every pure decomposition of a state `ω` averages this function to the same number, the upper envelope of `A₁, …, Aₙ` at `ω`. To see this, cut the pure states into small pieces on each of which one `Aᵢ` is nearly the largest, and glue the pieces with refinement. These test functions and their differences are dense among all continuous functions, so two pure decompositions of the same state agree.
ii. Key results
- `StateSpace.maxApply` is the largest expectation value of a state on finitely many observables. - `PureState.integral_maxApply_eq` proves that, when ensembles refine, a pure decomposition averages the largest value to the upper envelope. - `EnsemblesRefine.eq_of_toPositive_eq` proves that two measures on the pure states giving the same positive functional are equal. This is **Choquet–Meyer uniqueness**. - `EnsemblesRefine.hasUniquePureDecomposition` proves that, when ensembles refine, a pure decomposition is unique.
iii. Table of contents
- A. The largest value on a finite family
- B. Integrating the largest value
- C. Integrating the largest value when ensembles refine
- D. Density of largest values
- E. Uniqueness
- F. Unique pure decompositions
iv. References
- G. Choquet and P.-A. Meyer, *Existence et unicité des représentations intégrales dans les convexes compacts quelconques*, Ann. Inst. Fourier 13 (1963), 139–154. - E. M. Alfsen, *Compact Convex Sets and Boundary Integrals*, Springer, 1971, ch. II.3.
A. The largest value on a finite family
B. Integrating the largest value
C. Integrating the largest value when ensembles refine
D. Density of largest values
E. Uniqueness
F. Unique pure decompositions
33 declarations
The upper envelope at a pure state is at most the supremum of expectation values
Let be a pure state in the state space of a real vector space . Let be a family of elements in and be a real number. If the expectation value of on every element of the family is bounded by (i.e., for all ), then the upper envelope of the family evaluated at is also at most .
Maximum expectation value of a finite family of observables
Given an Archimedean order-unit space and a finite family of observables in , the function maps each state in the state space to the maximum expectation value . The resulting object is a continuous real-valued function on the state space, denoted by .
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of observables in . For any state in the state space , the maximum expectation value function evaluated at is equal to the maximum of the expectation values of the family, i.e., where denotes the value of the state (viewed as a unital positive linear map) applied to the observable .
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and its state space. For any finite family of observables in and any state , the expectation value of an individual observable is bounded above by the maximum expectation value of the family:
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be its state space. Let be a finite family of observables in . For any state and any real number , if the expectation value of each observable satisfies for all , then the maximum expectation value also satisfies .
The maximum expectation value is attained for some
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and its state space. Given a finite family of observables in , then for any state , there exists an index such that the maximum expectation value of the family is attained at , i.e.,
for an upper bound of
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be a finite family of observables in . If is an upper bound of this family (i.e., for all ), then for any state in the state space , the maximum expectation value of the family satisfies:
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and its state space. For any finite family of elements in and any state , the absolute value of the maximum expectation value satisfies: where denotes the order-unit norm.
The maximum expectation value of a single observable is its expectation value
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be its state space. For any observable and any state , the maximum expectation value of the singleton family evaluated at is equal to the expectation value .
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space with state space . For any two finite families of observables and , let be the continuous function on defined by . Then the maximum expectation value function for the combined family (the disjoint union of the two families) is the pointwise supremum of the individual functions: where denotes the pointwise maximum in the space of continuous functions .
Additivity of the maximum expectation value function over families of observables
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space with state space . Given two finite families of observables and , let and be the continuous functions on the state space defined by and , respectively. Then the function corresponding to the family of sums is equal to the sum of these two functions. That is, for every state ,
The maximum expectation value is integrable over pure states
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be a finite family of observables in . For any measure defined on the set of pure states of , the function that maps each pure state to the maximum expectation value is integrable with respect to .
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of observables in . Let be a finite measure on the set of pure states , and let be the positive linear functional defined by . Then the integral of the maximum expectation value over the pure states is bounded above by the upper envelope of the family evaluated at : where .
The positive functional of a measure restricted to the universal set equals the original positive functional
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be a finite measure on the set of pure states . Let be the positive linear functional defined by integrating elements of against , i.e., . The restriction of to the universal set of pure states, denoted , yields the same positive linear functional as itself:
Additivity of induced positive functionals under domain partition
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be a measure on its set of pure states . For any subset and any measurable set , the positive linear functional induced by the restriction of the measure to a set satisfies: where the induced functional for a measure is defined by .
is an upper bound for
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space with order unit and order-unit norm . For any finite family of elements in , the element is an upper bound for the set . That is, for every ,
The Upper Envelope of a Finite Family is Bounded by the Integral of the Maxima and the Sum of Norms
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of elements in . Let be a finite measure on the set of pure states . For any subset , let be the positive linear functional defined by integrating observables over against , i.e., . Then the upper envelope of the family evaluated at satisfies: where denotes the order-unit norm of and is the measure of the set . In other words, on any piece , the upper envelope exceeds the integral of the largest expectation value by at most twice the sum of the norms of the family times the mass of the piece.
in a Neighborhood of a Pure State
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of observables in . Let be a finite measure on the set of pure states . For any pure state and any , there exists an open neighborhood of such that for every measurable subset , the upper envelope evaluated on the positive functional satisfies the inequality: where is the measure of the set and is the maximum expectation value of the family at the state .
The upper envelope of a non-empty family at the zero functional is
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a non-empty index set. For any finite family of observables in and any finite measure on the set of pure states , let be the positive linear functional on induced by the restriction of to the empty set (which is the zero functional). Then the upper envelope of the family evaluated at satisfies .
Upper envelope inequalities on and imply the inequality on
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and a finite family of observables in . Let be a finite measure on the set of pure states . For any subset , let denote the positive linear functional on defined by . Given a subset and a measurable subset , if there exist constants such that: 1. 2. then it holds that:
The upper envelope inequality for pure states is preserved under finite unions of sets.
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of observables in . Let be a finite measure on the set of pure states . For any measurable set , let be the positive linear functional on defined by the integral: Suppose there exists a collection of measurable sets and a constant such that for every , any measurable subset satisfies the inequality: where denotes the upper envelope of the family (the evaluation of the state at the supremum of in the state space). Then, for any finite collection of indices , if a measurable set is contained in the union , the same inequality holds:
Upper Envelope Bound by the Integral of the Maximum over a Compact Set of Pure States
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be a finite family of observables in . Let denote the set of pure states of . For any finite measure on , any compact subset , and any positive real number , the upper envelope of the family evaluated at the positive linear functional (where ) satisfies the inequality: where is the measure of the set .
Finite regular measures on pure states are inner regular
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let denote the set of its pure states. Given a finite regular measure on and any positive real number , there exists a compact subset such that the measure of the complement of is less than , i.e., .
Upper Bound for by Integral of Maximum Expectation plus
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let denote the set of its pure states. Let be a finite family of observables in . Suppose is a regular probability measure on , and let be the positive linear functional defined by . For any , the upper envelope of at is bounded as follows: where is the order-unit norm of .
Integral of the Maximum Expectation Value Equals the Upper Envelope at the Barycenter
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space satisfying the ensemble refinement property. Let be a regular probability measure on the set of pure states of , and let be its barycenter, defined by the positive linear functional for all . For any finite family of observables in , the integral of the maximum expectation value over the pure states is equal to the upper envelope of evaluated at the barycenter : where denotes the upper envelope of the family of observables.
Set of differences of maximum expectation values
Given an Archimedean order-unit space and its state space , `maxApplyDiffs` is the set of continuous real-valued functions on that can be expressed as the difference between two maximum expectation value functions. Specifically, a function belongs to this set if there exist finite non-empty index sets and , and families of observables and in , such that for every state :
The set of differences of maximum expectation values is closed under supremum.
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be its state space. Let be the set of continuous real-valued functions (known as `maxApplyDiffs`) that can be expressed as the difference between two maximum expectation value functions. That is, if there exist finite non-empty index sets and families of observables in such that for every state : For any two functions , their pointwise supremum , defined by , is also an element of .
If , then
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be its state space. Let be the space of continuous real-valued functions on the state space. The set consists of functions that can be expressed as the difference of two maximum expectation value functions: where and are finite non-empty index sets and are families of observables in . This theorem states that if a function belongs to , then its negation also belongs to .
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be its state space. Let be the set of continuous real-valued functions on that can be expressed as the difference between two maximum expectation value functions; that is, a function is in if there exist finite non-empty index sets and and families of observables and in such that for every state , For any two functions , their pointwise infimum , defined by , is also an element of .
The set of differences of maximum expectation values strongly separates points on the state space
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and be its state space. Let be the set of continuous functions that can be expressed as the difference of two maximum expectation values, i.e., for some finite non-empty index sets and observables . Then the set strongly separates the points of . This means that for any two distinct states , there exists a function such that , and for every state , there exists a function such that .
Differences of maximum expectation values are dense in
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space and let be its state space. Let be the space of continuous real-valued functions on equipped with the topology of uniform convergence. Let be the set of functions of the form where and are finite non-empty index sets and are observables. Then the topological closure of is the entire space . That is, the differences of maximum expectation values are dense among continuous functions on the state space.
Measures on pure states with the same resultant functional have equal integrals for all
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space with state space . Let and be finite measures on the set of pure states . If and represent the same positive linear functional on (i.e., , meaning for all ), then for any continuous function , the integral of with respect to the pushforward of to the state space equals the integral of with respect to the pushforward of : where is the inclusion map.
Ensemble refinement implies uniqueness of pure decompositions (Choquet–Meyer uniqueness)
Let be an Archimedean order-unit space. Suppose satisfies the ensemble refinement property, meaning that for any two finite families of positive linear functionals and on such that , there exists a common refinement . If a state has a pure decomposition (i.e., there exists a regular probability measure on the set of pure states of such that for all ), then this decomposition is unique.
