Physlib

Physlib.StringTheory.FTheory.SU5.Quanta.Basic

Quanta of representations

i. Overview

In SU(5) × U(1) F-theory theory, each 5-bar and 10d representation carries with it the quantum numbers of their U(1) charges and their fluxes.

In this module we define the data structure for these quanta and properties thereof.

ii. Key results

- `Quanta` : The structure containing the quantum numbers of the 5-bar and 10d representations, as well as the charges of the `Hd` and `Hu` particles. - `Quanta.liftCharge` : Lifting a `ChargeSpectrum` to a multiset of `Quanta` which have no chiral exotics and no zero fluxes. - `Quanta.AnomalyCancellation` : The anomaly cancellation conditions on a `Quanta`.

iii. Table of contents

- A. The Quanta structure - A.1. Repr instance on `Quanta` - A.2. Extensionality lemma - A.3. Decidable equality instance - A.4. Map to the underlying `ChargeSpectrum` - B. The reduction of a `Quanta` - C. Lifting a charge spectrum to quanta with no exotics or zero fluxes - C.1. Simplification of membership in the liftCharge multiset - C.2. Charge spectrum of a lifted quanta - D. Anomaly cancellation conditions - D.1. The anomaly coefficient of Hd - D.2. The anomaly coefficient of Hu - D.3. The anomaly cancellation condition propositions - D.3.1. The propositions are decidable

iv. References

A reference for the anomaly cancellation conditions is arXiv:1401.5084 equation 22.

A. The Quanta structure

A.1. Repr instance on `Quanta`

A.2. Extensionality lemma

A.3. Decidable equality instance

A.4. Map to the underlying `ChargeSpectrum`

B. The reduction of a `Quanta`

C. Lifting a charge spectrum to quanta with no exotics or zero fluxes

C.1. Simplification of membership in the liftCharge multiset

C.2. Charge spectrum of a lifted quanta

D. Anomaly cancellation conditions

There are two anomaly cancellation conditions in the SU(5)×U(1) model which involve the `U(1)` charges. These are

- `∑ᵢ qᵢ Nᵢ + ∑ₐ qₐ Nₐ = 0` where the first sum is over all 5-bar representations and the second is over all 10d representations. - `∑ᵢ qᵢ² Nᵢ + 3 * ∑ₐ qₐ² Nₐ = 0` where the first sum is over all 5-bar representations and the second is over all 10d representations.

According to arXiv:1401.5084 it is unclear whether this second condition should necessarily be imposed.

D.1. The anomaly coefficient of Hd

D.2. The anomaly coefficient of Hu

D.3. The anomaly cancellation condition propositions

#### D.3.1. The propositions are decidable

18 declarations

instance

Representation of `Quanta` as qHd,qHu,F,T\langle q_{H_d}, q_{H_u}, F, T \rangle

This definition provides an instance of the `Repr` typeclass for the `Quanta 𝓩` structure, which defines how to format an element as a string for display. For a given `Quanta` object xx, its string representation is given by the tuple qHd,qHu,F,T\langle q_{H_d}, q_{H_u}, F, T \rangle, where qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are the U(1)U(1) charges of the HdH_d and HuH_u particles, FF denotes the data for the 5-bar representations, and TT denotes the data for the 10-dimensional representations.

theorem

Equality of components implies equality of `Quanta` objects

Let Z\mathcal{Z} be a type. For any two `Quanta` objects x,yx, y over Z\mathcal{Z}, if their Higgs charges qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are equal (x.qHd=y.qHdx.q_{H_d} = y.q_{H_d} and x.qHu=y.qHux.q_{H_u} = y.q_{H_u}), and their flux data FF and TT for the 5ˉ\bar{\mathbf{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representations respectively are equal (x.F=y.Fx.F = y.F and x.T=y.Tx.T = y.T), then the two objects are equal (x=yx = y).

instance

Equality x=yx = y for x,yQuanta Zx, y \in \text{Quanta } \mathcal{Z} is decidable

For any type Z\mathcal{Z} with decidable equality, the equality between two objects x,yQuanta Zx, y \in \text{Quanta } \mathcal{Z} is decidable. This is established by checking the equality of their four constituent fields: the U(1)U(1) charges x.qHd=y.qHdx.q_{H_d} = y.q_{H_d} and x.qHu=y.qHux.q_{H_u} = y.q_{H_u}, and the flux data x.F=y.Fx.F = y.F and x.T=y.Tx.T = y.T.

definition

Charge spectrum of a `Quanta` object xx

This function maps a `Quanta` object xx (which contains quantum numbers for SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) representations) to its corresponding `ChargeSpectrum`. It extracts the U(1)U(1) charges qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} of the Higgs particles HdH_d and HuH_u, and determines the finite sets of charges Q5ˉQ_{\bar{\mathbf{5}}} and Q10Q_{\mathbf{10}} by extracting all unique charges present in the flux data FF and TT associated with the 5ˉ\bar{\mathbf{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representations, respectively.

theorem

The HdH_d charge of toCharges(x)\text{toCharges}(x) is x.qHdx.q_{H_d}

For any `Quanta` object xx representing the quantum numbers of SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) representations, the U(1)U(1) charge of the HdH_d Higgs particle in the corresponding charge spectrum, denoted (toCharges x).qHd(\text{toCharges } x).q_{H_d}, is equal to the charge x.qHdx.q_{H_d} defined in the original object.

theorem

The HuH_u charge of toCharges(x)\text{toCharges}(x) is x.qHux.q_{H_u}

For any `Quanta` object xx representing the quantum numbers of SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) representations, the U(1)U(1) charge of the HuH_u Higgs particle in the corresponding charge spectrum, denoted (toCharges x).qHu(\text{toCharges } x).q_{H_u}, is equal to the charge x.qHux.q_{H_u} defined in the original object.

definition

Reduction of a `Quanta` object by summing fluxes per charge

The reduction of a `Quanta` object xx, denoted as reduce(x)\text{reduce}(x), is a new `Quanta` object that preserves the U(1)U(1) charges of the Higgs fields qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} from xx. For the 5ˉ\mathbf{\bar{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representations, the respective flux collections FF and TT are replaced by their reduced versions, in which all fluxes corresponding to the same U(1)U(1) charge (or representation) are summed together.

definition

Lifting a charge spectrum to a multiset of quanta without exotics or zero fluxes

Given a charge spectrum cc of an SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) model, this function constructs a multiset of all possible `Quanta` objects that correspond to that spectrum. Each `Quanta` object in the resulting multiset preserves the U(1)U(1) charges of the Higgs fields qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} from the spectrum cc. The 5ˉ\mathbf{\bar{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representation-specific quanta are obtained by lifting the respective charge components c.Q5c.Q_5 and c.Q10c.Q_{10} using `FiveQuanta.liftCharge` and `TenQuanta.liftCharge`. The resulting multiset contains only those configurations that do not have chiral exotics and have no zero fluxes.

theorem

xliftCharge(c)x \in \text{liftCharge}(c) if and only if Higgs charges and representation quanta match

For a charge spectrum cc and a quanta object xx in an SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) F-theory model, xx is an element of the multiset of lifted quanta liftCharge(c)\text{liftCharge}(c) if and only if the following conditions are met: 1. The U(1)U(1) charges of the Higgs fields HdH_d and HuH_u in xx match those in cc (x.qHd=c.qHdx.q_{H_d} = c.q_{H_d} and x.qHu=c.qHux.q_{H_u} = c.q_{H_u}). 2. The 5ˉ\mathbf{\bar{5}} representation quanta FF of xx are in the lifted multiset of the charge component c.Q5c.Q_5. 3. The 10\mathbf{10} representation quanta TT of xx are in the lifted multiset of the charge component c.Q10c.Q_{10}.

theorem

x.toCharges=cx.\text{toCharges} = c for xliftCharge(c)x \in \text{liftCharge}(c)

In an SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) F-theory model, let cc be a charge spectrum and xx be a quanta object. If xx is an element of the multiset liftCharge(c)\text{liftCharge}(c), which consists of all valid quantum configurations (fluxes and charges) compatible with the spectrum cc that have no chiral exotics or zero fluxes, then the charge spectrum derived from xx is equal to cc (i.e., x.toCharges=cx.\text{toCharges} = c).

definition

Anomaly cancellation coefficients (qHd,qHd2)(q_{H_d}, q_{H_d}^2) for the HdH_d particle

For a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z}, given an optional U(1)U(1) charge qHdZq_{H_d} \in \mathcal{Z} associated with the HdH_d particle, the anomaly cancellation coefficients are defined as the pair (qHd,qHd2)Z×Z(q_{H_d}, q_{H_d}^2) \in \mathcal{Z} \times \mathcal{Z}. If the charge is not provided (represented as `none`), the coefficients are (0,0)(0, 0).

theorem

`HdAnomalyCoefficient` Commutes with Ring Homomorphisms

Let Z\mathcal{Z} and Z1\mathcal{Z}_1 be commutative rings, and let f:ZZ1f: \mathcal{Z} \to \mathcal{Z}_1 be a ring homomorphism. For any optional U(1)U(1) charge qHdq_{H_d} associated with the HdH_d particle, applying the anomaly coefficient function to the mapped charge f(qHd)f(q_{H_d}) (where ff maps `none` to `none`) is equivalent to applying ff component-wise to the resulting pair of anomaly coefficients. That is, HdAnomalyCoefficient(f(qHd))=(f(c1),f(c2))\text{HdAnomalyCoefficient}(f(q_{H_d})) = (f(c_1), f(c_2)) where (c1,c2)=HdAnomalyCoefficient(qHd)(c_1, c_2) = \text{HdAnomalyCoefficient}(q_{H_d}) is the pair of coefficients in Z×Z\mathcal{Z} \times \mathcal{Z}.

definition

Anomaly cancellation coefficients for the HuH_u particle

For a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z}, given an optional U(1)U(1) charge qHuq_{H_u} associated with the HuH_u particle, the function returns a pair of anomaly cancellation coefficients in Z×Z\mathcal{Z} \times \mathcal{Z} defined by: {(0,0)if qHu=none(q,q2)if qHu=q \begin{cases} (0, 0) & \text{if } q_{H_u} = \text{none} \\ (-q, -q^2) & \text{if } q_{H_u} = q \end{cases} These values represent the contribution of the HuH_u particle to the linear and quadratic U(1)U(1) anomaly cancellation conditions in the SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) model.

theorem

Ring Homomorphisms Commute with HuH_u Anomaly Coefficients

Let Z\mathcal{Z} and Z1\mathcal{Z}_1 be commutative rings and f:ZZ1f: \mathcal{Z} \to \mathcal{Z}_1 be a ring homomorphism. For an optional U(1)U(1) charge qHuq_{H_u} associated with the HuH_u particle, the anomaly coefficient function commutes with the ring homomorphism ff in the following sense: HuAnomalyCoefficient(map fqHu)=(f(x),f(y)) \text{HuAnomalyCoefficient}(\text{map } f \, q_{H_u}) = (f(x), f(y)) where (x,y)=HuAnomalyCoefficient(qHu)(x, y) = \text{HuAnomalyCoefficient}(q_{H_u}). Here, map f\text{map } f denotes the application of ff to the charge if it exists (returning `none` otherwise), and the right-hand side represents the application of ff to each component of the anomaly coefficient pair in Z×Z\mathcal{Z} \times \mathcal{Z}.

definition

Linear Anomaly Cancellation Condition: qN=0\sum q N = 0

In the SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) F-theory model, for a given set of quanta QQ over a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z}, the linear anomaly cancellation condition is the proposition that the sum of the U(1)U(1) charge contributions from the Higgs particles and the matter representations vanishes. Specifically, the condition is given by: qHdqHu+iqiNi+aqaNa=0 q_{H_d} - q_{H_u} + \sum_{i} q_i N_i + \sum_{a} q_a N_a = 0 where qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are the U(1)U(1) charges of the HdH_d and HuH_u particles respectively, the first sum corresponds to the 5\overline{\mathbf{5}} representations with charges qiq_i and multiplicities (fluxes) NiN_i, and the second sum corresponds to the 10\mathbf{10} representations with charges qaq_a and multiplicities NaN_a.

definition

Quartic Anomaly Cancellation Condition: q2N=0\sum q^2 N = 0

In the SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) F-theory model, for a given set of quanta QQ over a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z}, the quartic anomaly cancellation condition is the proposition that the sum of the quadratic U(1)U(1) charge contributions from the Higgs particles and the matter representations vanishes. Specifically, the condition is given by: qHd2qHu2+iqi2Ni+3aqa2Na=0 q_{H_d}^2 - q_{H_u}^2 + \sum_{i} q_i^2 N_i + 3 \sum_{a} q_a^2 N_a = 0 where qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are the U(1)U(1) charges of the HdH_d and HuH_u particles, the first sum corresponds to the 5\overline{\mathbf{5}} representations with charges qiq_i and multiplicities (fluxes) NiN_i, and the second sum corresponds to the 10\mathbf{10} representations with charges qaq_a and multiplicities NaN_a.

instance

The linear anomaly cancellation condition is decidable

In the SU(5)×U(1)SU(5) \times U(1) F-theory model, for a given set of quanta QQ defined over a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z} with decidable equality, the linear anomaly cancellation condition is a decidable proposition. Specifically, it is decidable whether the sum of U(1)U(1) charge contributions from the Higgs particles (Hd,HuH_d, H_u) and the matter representations (5,10\mathbf{\overline{5}}, \mathbf{10}) vanishes: qHdqHu+iqiNi+aqaNa=0 q_{H_d} - q_{H_u} + \sum_{i} q_i N_i + \sum_{a} q_a N_a = 0 where qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are the U(1)U(1) charges of the HdH_d and HuH_u particles, and the sums represent the contributions from the 5\mathbf{\overline{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representations respectively.

instance

Decidability of the quartic anomaly cancellation condition q2N=0\sum q^2 N = 0 for QQ

For a set of quanta QQ defined over a commutative ring Z\mathcal{Z} that has decidable equality, it is decidable whether QQ satisfies the quartic anomaly cancellation condition. This condition is expressed as: qHd2qHu2+iqi2Ni+3aqa2Na=0 q_{H_d}^2 - q_{H_u}^2 + \sum_{i} q_i^2 N_i + 3 \sum_{a} q_a^2 N_a = 0 where qHdq_{H_d} and qHuq_{H_u} are the U(1)U(1) charges of the Higgs particles HdH_d and HuH_u, and the sums are taken over the 5\overline{\mathbf{5}} and 10\mathbf{10} representations with U(1)U(1) charges qq and multiplicities (fluxes) NN.