Physlib

Physlib.QuantumMechanics.DDimensions.Operators.Uncertainty

Uncertainty bounds for partial linear maps

i. Overview

In this module we prove abstract Robertson and Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bounds for symmetric partial linear maps on a complex inner product space. The statements are independent of any concrete position or momentum operator.

The centered-commutator results use only the domain assumptions needed to form the centered vectors. The raw-commutator results add the second-order domain hypotheses required to apply `A` to `Bψ` and `B` to `Aψ`.

ii. Key results

- `inner_im_of_commutator_eq` : an anti-Hermitian commutator identity fixes the imaginary part of an inner product. - `centeredCommutatorExpectation` : the scalar commutator of the centered vectors. - `rawCommutatorExpectation` : the expectation of the raw commutator on a state. - `inner_centered_commutator_of_raw_commutator` : a raw commutator expectation gives the centered commutator expectation. - `state_uncertainty_squared_of_centered_commutator` : the Robertson squared bound from a centered commutator identity. - `state_uncertainty_squared_with_covariance_of_centered_commutator` : the strengthened Robertson–Schrödinger bound. - `state_uncertainty_of_centered_commutator` : the standard-deviation form of the bound. - `state_uncertainty_squared_of_raw_commutator`, `state_uncertainty_squared_with_covariance_of_raw_commutator`, and `state_uncertainty_of_raw_commutator` : variants using a raw commutator expectation.

iii. Table of contents

  • A. Inner product lemmas
  • B. Centered commutator bounds
  • C. Raw commutator bounds

iv. References

  • [H. P. Robertson, *The Uncertainty Principle* (1929)][robertson1929uncertainty].
  • [E. Schrodinger, *Zum Heisenbergschen Unscharfeprinzip* (1930)][schrodinger1930heisenberg].
  • [B. C. Hall, *Quantum Theory for Mathematicians*, Chapter 12][hall2013quantum].

A. Inner product lemmas

B. Centered commutator bounds

C. Raw commutator bounds

14 declarations

theorem

Imu,v=c/2\text{Im}\langle u, v \rangle = c / 2 given u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For any vectors u,vHu, v \in H and any real number cc, if the difference between the inner products satisfies the identity u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c, then the imaginary part of the inner product is given by Im(u,v)=c/2\text{Im}(\langle u, v \rangle) = c / 2.

theorem

u,v2=(Reu,v)2+(c/2)2|\langle u, v \rangle|^2 = (\text{Re} \langle u, v \rangle)^2 + (c/2)^2 for Commutator Constant cc

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For any vectors u,vHu, v \in H and any real number cc, if the condition u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = ic holds (where ii is the imaginary unit), then the squared modulus of the inner product satisfies u,v2=(Reu,v)2+(c2)2|\langle u, v \rangle|^2 = (\text{Re} \langle u, v \rangle)^2 + \left( \frac{c}{2} \right)^2 where Reu,v\text{Re} \langle u, v \rangle denotes the real part of the inner product.

theorem

The Commutator of Centered Vectors Equals the Commutator of Raw Vectors

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For any unit vector ψH\psi \in H (with ψ=1\|\psi\| = 1) and any vectors a,bHa, b \in H, let μa,μbR\mu_a, \mu_b \in \mathbb{R} be real numbers representing the expectation values such that ψ,a=μa\langle \psi, a \rangle = \mu_a, a,ψ=μa\langle a, \psi \rangle = \mu_a, ψ,b=μb\langle \psi, b \rangle = \mu_b, and b,ψ=μb\langle b, \psi \rangle = \mu_b. Then the following identity holds: aμaψ,bμbψbμbψ,aμaψ=a,bb,a. \langle a - \mu_a \psi, b - \mu_b \psi \rangle - \langle b - \mu_b \psi, a - \mu_a \psi \rangle = \langle a, b \rangle - \langle b, a \rangle. Here, ,\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle denotes the complex inner product.

theorem

ψ,[A,B]ψ=Aψ,BψBψ,Aψ\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle = \langle A\psi, B\psi \rangle - \langle B\psi, A\psi \rangle for Symmetric Operators A,BA, B

Let HH be a complex inner product space. Suppose AA and BB are symmetric partial linear maps on HH. Let ψH\psi \in H be a vector in the domains of both AA and BB (denoted dom(A)\text{dom}(A) and dom(B)\text{dom}(B)) such that Aψdom(B)A\psi \in \text{dom}(B) and Bψdom(A)B\psi \in \text{dom}(A). For any real number cc, if the expectation value of the commutator of AA and BB on the state ψ\psi satisfies ψ,(ABBA)ψ=ic\langle \psi, (AB - BA)\psi \rangle = ic where ii is the imaginary unit, then the following identity holds: Aψ,BψBψ,Aψ=ic.\langle A\psi, B\psi \rangle - \langle B\psi, A\psi \rangle = ic. Here ,\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle denotes the complex inner product on HH.

definition

Centered commutator expectation u,vv,u\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For two partial linear maps AA and BB on HH and a vector ψ\psi in the intersection of their domains, the centered commutator expectation is the complex number defined by: u,vv,u \langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle where u=AψAψψu = A\psi - \langle A \rangle_\psi \psi and v=BψBψψv = B\psi - \langle B \rangle_\psi \psi are the centered vectors of AA and BB at ψ\psi, and Tψ=Reψ,Tψ\langle T \rangle_\psi = \text{Re} \langle \psi, T\psi \rangle denotes the expectation value of an operator TT. Here, ,\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle denotes the complex inner product on HH.

definition

Raw commutator expectation ψ,[A,B]ψ\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For two partial linear maps A,BA, B on HH, and a vector ψH\psi \in H, suppose ψ\psi is in the domains of both AA and BB (denoted dom(A)\text{dom}(A) and dom(B)\text{dom}(B)). If the second-order domain conditions are satisfied—specifically, that Aψdom(B)A\psi \in \text{dom}(B) and Bψdom(A)B\psi \in \text{dom}(A)—then the raw commutator expectation is the complex number given by the inner product ψ,(ABBA)ψC\langle \psi, (AB - BA)\psi \rangle_{\mathbb{C}}. Here, ,C\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle_{\mathbb{C}} denotes the complex inner product on HH.

theorem

(c/2)2(uv)2(|c|/2)^2 \le (\|u\| \|v\|)^2 given u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c

Let HH be a complex inner product space. For any vectors u,vHu, v \in H and any real number cc, if the identity u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c holds (where ii is the imaginary unit), then the following inequality is satisfied: (c2)2(uv)2 \left( \frac{|c|}{2} \right)^2 \le (\|u\| \cdot \|v\|)^2 where ,\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle denotes the complex inner product and \|\cdot\| denotes the associated norm.

theorem

Robertson squared uncertainty bound (c/2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B)(|c|/2)^2 \le \text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) from centered commutator identity

Let HH be a complex inner product space. Let AA and BB be partial linear maps on HH, and let ψ\psi be a vector in the intersection of their domains. Suppose the centered commutator expectation of AA and BB with respect to ψ\psi satisfies the identity u,vv,u=ic \langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, where u=AψAψψu = A\psi - \langle A \rangle_\psi \psi and v=BψBψψv = B\psi - \langle B \rangle_\psi \psi are the centered vectors, and Tψ=Reψ,Tψ\langle T \rangle_\psi = \text{Re} \langle \psi, T\psi \rangle is the expectation value. Then the squared Robertson uncertainty bound holds: (c2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B) \left( \frac{|c|}{2} \right)^2 \le \text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) where Varψ(T)=TψTψψ2\text{Var}_\psi(T) = \|T\psi - \langle T \rangle_\psi \psi\|^2 denotes the variance of a map TT in the state ψ\psi.

theorem

Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bound: Covψ(A,B)2+(c/2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B)\text{Cov}_\psi(A, B)^2 + (c/2)^2 \leq \text{Var}_\psi(A) \text{Var}_\psi(B)

Let HH be a complex inner product space, and let AA and BB be partial linear maps on HH. For a vector ψ\psi in the intersection of the domains of AA and BB, suppose the centered commutator expectation satisfies the identity u,vv,u=ic\langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, where u=AψAψψu = A\psi - \langle A \rangle_\psi \psi and v=BψBψψv = B\psi - \langle B \rangle_\psi \psi are the centered vectors and Tψ=Reψ,Tψ\langle T \rangle_\psi = \text{Re} \langle \psi, T\psi \rangle is the expectation value. Then the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bound holds: Covψ(A,B)2+(c2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B) \text{Cov}_\psi(A, B)^2 + \left( \frac{c}{2} \right)^2 \leq \text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) where Varψ(T)=TψTψψ2\text{Var}_\psi(T) = \|T\psi - \langle T \rangle_\psi \psi\|^2 is the variance of an operator TT and Covψ(A,B)=Reu,v\text{Cov}_\psi(A, B) = \text{Re} \langle u, v \rangle is the covariance of AA and BB in the state ψ\psi.

theorem

Robertson uncertainty bound c2σψ(A)σψ(B)\frac{|c|}{2} \le \sigma_\psi(A) \cdot \sigma_\psi(B) from centered commutator identity

Let HH be a complex inner product space. Let AA and BB be partial linear maps on HH, and let ψ\psi be a vector in the intersection of the domains of AA and BB. Suppose the centered commutator expectation satisfies the identity u,vv,u=ic \langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, where u=AψAψψu = A\psi - \langle A \rangle_\psi \psi and v=BψBψψv = B\psi - \langle B \rangle_\psi \psi are the centered vectors, and Tψ=Reψ,Tψ\langle T \rangle_\psi = \text{Re} \langle \psi, T\psi \rangle is the expectation value. Then the Robertson uncertainty bound in terms of standard deviations holds: c2σψ(A)σψ(B) \frac{|c|}{2} \le \sigma_\psi(A) \cdot \sigma_\psi(B) where σψ(T)=TψTψψ2\sigma_\psi(T) = \sqrt{\|T\psi - \langle T \rangle_\psi \psi\|^2} denotes the standard deviation of a map TT in the state ψ\psi.

theorem

Centered commutator expectation equals raw commutator expectation icic

Let HH be a complex inner product space. Let AA and BB be symmetric partial linear maps on HH. For a vector ψ\psi in the intersection of the domains of A,B,AB,A, B, AB, and BABA, let cc be a real number such that the raw commutator expectation satisfies ψ,[A,B]ψ=ic\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle = i c. Then the centered commutator expectation is also equal to ici c, i.e., u,vv,u=ic \langle u, v \rangle - \langle v, u \rangle = i c where u=(AAψ)ψu = (A - \langle A \rangle_\psi) \psi and v=(BBψ)ψv = (B - \langle B \rangle_\psi) \psi are the centered vectors of AA and BB at ψ\psi, and Tψ=Reψ,Tψ\langle T \rangle_\psi = \text{Re} \langle \psi, T\psi \rangle denotes the expectation value of an operator TT.

theorem

Squared Robertson uncertainty bound (c2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B)(\frac{|c|}{2})^2 \le \text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) from raw commutator expectation

Let HH be a complex inner product space. Let AA and BB be symmetric partial linear maps on HH, and let ψH\psi \in H be a vector in the domains of AA and BB satisfying the necessary second-order domain conditions. If the expectation of the raw commutator ψ,[A,B]ψ\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle is given by icic for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, then the squared Robertson uncertainty bound holds: (c2)2Varψ(A)Varψ(B)\left( \frac{|c|}{2} \right)^2 \le \text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) where Varψ(T)\text{Var}_\psi(T) denotes the variance of a partial linear map TT in the state ψ\psi.

theorem

Robertson–Schrödinger Uncertainty Relation for Raw Commutators

Let HH be a complex inner product space and let AA and BB be symmetric partial linear maps on HH. Let ψH\psi \in H be a state vector such that ψ\psi is in the domains of both AA and BB, and the second-order domain conditions Aψdom(B)A\psi \in \text{dom}(B) and Bψdom(A)B\psi \in \text{dom}(A) are satisfied. If the expectation value of the raw commutator [A,B]=ABBA[A, B] = AB - BA in the state ψ\psi is given by ψ,[A,B]ψ=ic\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle = ic for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, then the following inequality holds: Varψ(A)Varψ(B)Covψ(A,B)2+(c2)2\text{Var}_\psi(A) \cdot \text{Var}_\psi(B) \ge \text{Cov}_\psi(A, B)^2 + \left( \frac{c}{2} \right)^2 where Varψ(T)\text{Var}_\psi(T) denotes the variance of a map TT in state ψ\psi, and Covψ(A,B)\text{Cov}_\psi(A, B) denotes the covariance of AA and BB in state ψ\psi.

theorem

c2σψ(A)σψ(B)\frac{|c|}{2} \le \sigma_\psi(A) \sigma_\psi(B) from Raw Commutator Expectation

Let HH be a complex inner product space and let AA and BB be symmetric partial linear maps on HH. Let ψH\psi \in H be a vector such that ψ\psi is in the domains of both AA and BB, and the second-order domain conditions Aψdom(B)A\psi \in \text{dom}(B) and Bψdom(A)B\psi \in \text{dom}(A) are satisfied. If the expectation value of the raw commutator in the state ψ\psi is given by ψ,[A,B]ψ=ic\langle \psi, [A, B] \psi \rangle = ic for some cRc \in \mathbb{R}, then the following uncertainty bound holds: c2σψ(A)σψ(B)\frac{|c|}{2} \le \sigma_\psi(A) \cdot \sigma_\psi(B) where σψ(T)\sigma_\psi(T) denotes the standard deviation of the map TT in the state ψ\psi.