Physlib.QuantumMechanics.DDimensions.Operators.Uncertainty
Uncertainty bounds for partial linear maps
i. Overview
In this module we prove abstract Robertson and Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bounds for symmetric partial linear maps on a complex inner product space. The statements are independent of any concrete position or momentum operator.
The centered-commutator results use only the domain assumptions needed to form the centered vectors. The raw-commutator results add the second-order domain hypotheses required to apply `A` to `Bψ` and `B` to `Aψ`.
ii. Key results
- `inner_im_of_commutator_eq` : an anti-Hermitian commutator identity fixes the imaginary part of an inner product. - `centeredCommutatorExpectation` : the scalar commutator of the centered vectors. - `rawCommutatorExpectation` : the expectation of the raw commutator on a state. - `inner_centered_commutator_of_raw_commutator` : a raw commutator expectation gives the centered commutator expectation. - `state_uncertainty_squared_of_centered_commutator` : the Robertson squared bound from a centered commutator identity. - `state_uncertainty_squared_with_covariance_of_centered_commutator` : the strengthened Robertson–Schrödinger bound. - `state_uncertainty_of_centered_commutator` : the standard-deviation form of the bound. - `state_uncertainty_squared_of_raw_commutator`, `state_uncertainty_squared_with_covariance_of_raw_commutator`, and `state_uncertainty_of_raw_commutator` : variants using a raw commutator expectation.
iii. Table of contents
- A. Inner product lemmas
- B. Centered commutator bounds
- C. Raw commutator bounds
iv. References
- [H. P. Robertson, *The Uncertainty Principle* (1929)][robertson1929uncertainty].
- [E. Schrodinger, *Zum Heisenbergschen Unscharfeprinzip* (1930)][schrodinger1930heisenberg].
- [B. C. Hall, *Quantum Theory for Mathematicians*, Chapter 12][hall2013quantum].
A. Inner product lemmas
B. Centered commutator bounds
C. Raw commutator bounds
14 declarations
given
Let be a complex inner product space. For any vectors and any real number , if the difference between the inner products satisfies the identity , then the imaginary part of the inner product is given by .
for Commutator Constant
Let be a complex inner product space. For any vectors and any real number , if the condition holds (where is the imaginary unit), then the squared modulus of the inner product satisfies where denotes the real part of the inner product.
The Commutator of Centered Vectors Equals the Commutator of Raw Vectors
Let be a complex inner product space. For any unit vector (with ) and any vectors , let be real numbers representing the expectation values such that , , , and . Then the following identity holds: Here, denotes the complex inner product.
for Symmetric Operators
Let be a complex inner product space. Suppose and are symmetric partial linear maps on . Let be a vector in the domains of both and (denoted and ) such that and . For any real number , if the expectation value of the commutator of and on the state satisfies where is the imaginary unit, then the following identity holds: Here denotes the complex inner product on .
Centered commutator expectation
Let be a complex inner product space. For two partial linear maps and on and a vector in the intersection of their domains, the centered commutator expectation is the complex number defined by: where and are the centered vectors of and at , and denotes the expectation value of an operator . Here, denotes the complex inner product on .
Raw commutator expectation
Let be a complex inner product space. For two partial linear maps on , and a vector , suppose is in the domains of both and (denoted and ). If the second-order domain conditions are satisfied—specifically, that and —then the raw commutator expectation is the complex number given by the inner product . Here, denotes the complex inner product on .
given
Let be a complex inner product space. For any vectors and any real number , if the identity holds (where is the imaginary unit), then the following inequality is satisfied: where denotes the complex inner product and denotes the associated norm.
Robertson squared uncertainty bound from centered commutator identity
Let be a complex inner product space. Let and be partial linear maps on , and let be a vector in the intersection of their domains. Suppose the centered commutator expectation of and with respect to satisfies the identity for some , where and are the centered vectors, and is the expectation value. Then the squared Robertson uncertainty bound holds: where denotes the variance of a map in the state .
Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bound:
Let be a complex inner product space, and let and be partial linear maps on . For a vector in the intersection of the domains of and , suppose the centered commutator expectation satisfies the identity for some , where and are the centered vectors and is the expectation value. Then the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty bound holds: where is the variance of an operator and is the covariance of and in the state .
Robertson uncertainty bound from centered commutator identity
Let be a complex inner product space. Let and be partial linear maps on , and let be a vector in the intersection of the domains of and . Suppose the centered commutator expectation satisfies the identity for some , where and are the centered vectors, and is the expectation value. Then the Robertson uncertainty bound in terms of standard deviations holds: where denotes the standard deviation of a map in the state .
Centered commutator expectation equals raw commutator expectation
Let be a complex inner product space. Let and be symmetric partial linear maps on . For a vector in the intersection of the domains of and , let be a real number such that the raw commutator expectation satisfies . Then the centered commutator expectation is also equal to , i.e., where and are the centered vectors of and at , and denotes the expectation value of an operator .
Squared Robertson uncertainty bound from raw commutator expectation
Let be a complex inner product space. Let and be symmetric partial linear maps on , and let be a vector in the domains of and satisfying the necessary second-order domain conditions. If the expectation of the raw commutator is given by for some , then the squared Robertson uncertainty bound holds: where denotes the variance of a partial linear map in the state .
Robertson–Schrödinger Uncertainty Relation for Raw Commutators
Let be a complex inner product space and let and be symmetric partial linear maps on . Let be a state vector such that is in the domains of both and , and the second-order domain conditions and are satisfied. If the expectation value of the raw commutator in the state is given by for some , then the following inequality holds: where denotes the variance of a map in state , and denotes the covariance of and in state .
from Raw Commutator Expectation
Let be a complex inner product space and let and be symmetric partial linear maps on . Let be a vector such that is in the domains of both and , and the second-order domain conditions and are satisfied. If the expectation value of the raw commutator in the state is given by for some , then the following uncertainty bound holds: where denotes the standard deviation of the map in the state .
